Why in the News?
Despite strong GDP growth, a middle-class crisis threatens demand, stability, and India's demographic dividend, as rising geo-economic uncertainty deepens India's Middle-Class Vulnerability.
Middle-Class Economic Crisis
- Lack of job creation: The formal job market is failing to absorb the 8 million new graduates entering the workforce each year.
- The unemployment rate for graduates stands at 29.1%, nine times higher than for those who never attended school.
- Eroding traditional employment: Technological Displacement, driven by the rapid adoption of automation and artificial intelligence (AI), is removing routine cognitive jobs such as clerical work and IT services.
- Stagnant or declined real wages: Over the past decade, middle-income households saw an income growth of just 0.4% CAGR (2012-23 to 2023-24).
- Surging cost of living: Essential expenses like housing, education, and healthcare are seeing double-digit annual inflation and about 30% of Indian households have debt.
- Infrastructure Deficit: It increases the hidden Costs of living due to frequent power outages, erratic water supply and poor digital connectivity, necessitating costly private backups.
- Poor road infrastructure, public transit limitations, and traffic congestion result in lost productive hours.
Other reasons for the rising middle-class vulnerability
- Geopolitical impact: Increasing shortage of energy and fertilizers and rising food prices can hamper a large population and livelihood due to the war in West Asia and the Ukraine-Russia war.
- Welfare Exclusion: While lower-income groups are experiencing upward mobility supported by government welfare schemes, the middle class, which contributes 53% of all income tax filings, remains ineligible for these safety nets.
- Patriarchy and Gender Disparities: Combined with gender pay gaps and workplace discrimination, this underutilization of the female workforce leaves families highly vulnerable to single-income shocks.
- In India, the labour force participation rate among females is 32.4% and among males is 77.6% for 2025 (World Bank).
- Persistent caste-based economic stratification: It continues to shape opportunities, contributing to an uneven distribution of wealth within the middle class itself.
- More than 66% of Group C safai karmacharis employed across the central government come from SC, ST, or OBC backgrounds. (Department of Personnel and Training's annual report 2024-25).
- Corporate Concentration: The liberalization of the economy has concentrated market power in the hands of a few large corporations, impacting traditional middle-class entrepreneurs, business owners, etc.
Middle income class
|
Implications of middle-class vulnerability
- Economic Consequences
- Impact on growth: It poses a severe threat to India's broader macroeconomic stability as the middle class drives nearly 60% of domestic consumption.
- Depleted Savings and Capital: India's net household financial savings fell to a historic low of roughly 5 % of GDP, primarily due to rising retail debt and inflation impacting capital supply in the economy.
- Widening Wealth Inequality: The hollowing out of the middle class is accelerating the divide between the rich and the rest as the top 1% captures over 22% of national income. (World Inequality Lab)
- Socio-Political Consequences
- Social Consequences: Anxiety and depression medications are seeing massive sales growth, and financial stress is increasingly linked to a rising number of suicides among salaried urban professionals and students.
- According to the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) statistics, suicides due to financial stress rose from 4,970 in 2018 to over 7,000 in 2022.
- Trapped Mobility: As financial constraints tighten, middle-class families are forced to make difficult trade-offs such as delaying preventive healthcare, lower-quality education; severely threatens the human capital development of the next generation.
- Brain Drain: The lack of secure, well-paying jobs and declining quality of life is driving skilled professionals to migrate abroad in search of better opportunities, further depriving the domestic economy of valuable talent.
- Social Consequences: Anxiety and depression medications are seeing massive sales growth, and financial stress is increasingly linked to a rising number of suicides among salaried urban professionals and students.
Government Initiatives for alleviating middle class vulnerability
|
Way Forward
A more inclusive development approach, as suggested by the World Bank policy paper, proposes shifting welfare analysis from merely counting those below the poverty line to measuring how far people are from a reasonable standard of living, using well-being as a spectrum and giving greater weight to those furthest behind. Adopting tools like a Multi-Dimensional Vulnerability Index can help policymakers identify those most at risk and design targeted interventions.
